DQ | - Dynamic Quality |
OGC | - One Global Context |
OGT | - One Global Truth |
SOM | - Subject-Object Metaphysics |
SQ | - Static Quality |
Buridan's Assumptions | Reviewer's Assumptions | Comments/Comparison |
substance exists |
reality exists:
|
SOM reality is a tiny physical subset of reality's known actual part |
nonsubstance does not exist | unknown actual reality exists; nonactuality exists |
SOM's subjective realm exists and SOM's unknown exists |
classical objects are substantial and exist | quantum models exist |
ideal classical objects do not exist;
reality's quantum models (quantons) are, in general, none of these. See our obsfect definition. |
classical objects possess attributes or properties | quantum models interrelate; quantum models' interrelationships define them | reality's quantons are in interrelationships; a quanton's interrelationships define it |
truth value may be assessed only by propositions which exist |
|
here we see quantum reality's many truths, many contexts and many concomitant, included-middle logics, vis-à-vis SOM reality's OGT, OGC, and a single syllogistic logic |
|
bivalent both/and logic exists; infinite-value (fuzzy) logic exists; omnivalent (quantonic) logic exists |
here we see quantum reality's many truths, many contexts and many concomitant logics vis-à-vis SOM reality's OGT, OGC, and a single syllogistic logic |
propositions may exist or not exist and may alternate existence in time | all propositions may exhibit quantum-logical truth value in some quantum reality context(s) | here we see quantum reality's many truths... |
proposition meaning may change upon change of conventional global context | all propositions may exhibit an infinite variety of quantum-logical truth values in an infinite variety of quantum reality context(s) | here we see quantum reality's many truths... |
equiform propositions differ only when their truth conditions differ | n/a | |
equiform propositions may not be true and false simultaneously (e.g., p. 47 - parity, universality) | bivalent both/and logic exists; infinite-value (fuzzy) logic exists; omnivalent (quantonic) logic exists |
here we see quantum reality's many truths..."omniplex veritas" |
propositions which exist include terms whose suppositions stand for substance, objects, object properties, personal suppositions, or material suppositions | all quantum-logical propositions describe quantum-logical interrelationships among quantons (i.e., quantum models) | |
truth value is either true or false | truth may change continuously (we should say, quantumly, "truthings") | quantum flux imposes at least a Planck rate potential for change of quanton interrelationships (potentially faster assuming quanton changes are not synchronous to Planck's frequency) |
Buridan's Assumptions | Reviewer's Assumptions | Comments/Comparison |
true premises never entail a false conclusion | bivalent both/and logic exists; infinite-value (fuzzy) logic exists; omnivalent (quantonic) logic exists |
here we see quantum reality's many truths... Allow Doug to restate Buridan's assumption here: "...true premises never entail a false conclusion..." There is only one way Doug knows of that Buridan's assumption can be generally 'true.' Buridan is making other implicit assumptions:
But quantum~reality belies all of Buridan's assumptions! Reality is n¤t classically dialectical. Reality is quantum and exhibits many features:
So, in this case Buridan's assumption, "...true premises never entail a false conclusion..." is simply retarded, beyond retarded: moronic. Buridan is a moron for a simple reason: he bought into Parmenides', Plato's, and Aristotle's dialectic bogosities. Do your quantum due diligence. Read all of Doug's Quantum Connection. Then you will understand why Doug writes: Both in a local quantum~comtexting and in many both local and n¤nlocal quantum~comtextings:
Bottom Line: Ideal classical OGCs and all their objective, state-ic premises are bogus, hylic intellectual garbage. Doug - 23May2010. |
contexts exist | an infinity of concurrent contexts exist | SOM assumes multiple contexts, but only one conventional context may be used for truth value assessment at one time; quantum reality assumes an infinity of contexts in concurrent existence |
selected context is conventional, established by both consensus and propositions under evaluation |
see comtext 14Mar2009 - Doug. |
SOM's OGC... |
once selected, a context becomes global for propositions and entailments under evaluation | see above | SOM's OGC... |
a proposition is:
|
for every quantum proposition there are an infinity of omnicoherent, omnimensional, omnicontexts with omnivalent truth value | |
an inconsistent proposition's truth value is false | bivalent both/and logic exists; infinite-value (fuzzy) logic exists; omnivalent (quantonic) logic exists |
|
every true proposition is contextually consistent | for every quantum proposition there are an infinity of omnicoherent, omnimensional, omnicontexts with omnivalent truth value | |
self-contradictory propositions are false |
see Doug's QELR of truth see Doug's CeodE 2004 Bases of Judgment Church of Reason Section 14Mar2009 - Doug. |
any contradiction in general quantum logic implies a context of a proposition needs expansion see: coquecigrues see: enthymeme see: enthymemetics see: partial see: wavefunction see: occur see: discriminate (quantum as omniscriminate) see: evolve see: wisdom, and see Doug's CeodE 2009 What is Gnosis? Doug - 14Mar2009. |
self-contradictory propositions appear both true and false simultaneously | n/a |
Compare classical and quantum simultaneity. Essentially classical notions of simultaneity and isochrony become quantum memeos of phasicity and phasicityings. See 'Absence of Global Isochrony and Implications' below. Doug - 10Jan2010. |
self-referent propositions exist | n/a | |
non-self-referent propositions exist | n/a | |
sophisms exist
|
n/a | |
paradox arises only if we can prove a proposition false, then it follows that a proposition is true | n/a | any contradiction in general quantum logic implies a context of a proposition needs expansion |
dialecticians may declare certain concepts non-existent, for example:
|
n/a | in quantum reality all is possible; no concept is absurd or unreasonable |
dialecticians may declare certain
results of propositions absurd, for example: - see discussion on signification on p. 13 |
n/a | in quantum reality all is possible; no concept is absurd or unreasonable |
|
|
|
classical syllogistic logic exists | quantum logic exists | axioms which attend this statement are almost unfathomable; we have a long way to go here |
classical logical reality is closed | our best current model of reality is quantum reality | it is your reviewer's conjecture that both quantum reality and thus quantum logic are open |
truth is absolute | change is absolute; truth is relative; truth may change continuously |
flux is crux |
tautologies exist | n/a | classical tautologies in a classical reality, when viewed from that classical reality immersed (subsumed) in quantum reality, may appear as sophisms (i.e., quantum flux may change any terms of any propositions continuously) |
change is analytic in classical time | flux quantizes change in quantum reality | integration of quantized change, or flux loop counts provide an illusion of time flow |
truth presides over change | change presides over substance and truth (flux is crux) | a la Pirsig, change (a metaphor of DQ) is reality's first good; truth (one type of SQ) is reality's second good |
'is' represents an ideal 'equals' | n/a | in general, quantons may change faster than Planck's rate, so any given quanton may not even be 'equal' to itself from Planck instant to Planck instant; more complex quanton are more likely to change from instant to instant |
classical schisms:
|
n/a | quantum reality replaces SOM's idea of schism with a quantum meme of unified quantum cohesive networks of locally autonomous complementary interrelationships |
SOM's domain of substance/existence is its domain of reason | quantum reality is a domain of reason | |
SOM's domain of reason is:
|
a quantum domain of reason is:
|
|
conventional SOM classical assumptions are adequate for practicing SOM's dialectical art | n/a | |
SOM's domain of chosen exclusive context does not change during proposition assessment | n/a | a quantum domain may change as often as Planck's rate |
Buridan's Assumptions | Reviewer's Quantum Assumptions | Comments/Comparison |
SOM's domain of chosen exclusive context does not affect proposition terms during assessment | quantum models interrelate | quantons may experience changes in interrelationships as often as Planck's rate |
SOM's domain of chosen exclusive context is separate from proposition terms during assessment:
SOM logic is lisr, stoppable, bivalent, unilateral, 1-1 correspondent, etc. All are problematic in quantum reality. Doug - 14Feb2007. |
quantum truth value is islandic-local and nondistributive and dependent on up to omni quantum~simultaneous possibilities of (see more recent c. 2004-2007 QELR of phase):
In Quantonics quantum reality's 'logic' is coquecigrues. Coquecigrues is self~other~referent~quantum~sophism. It is everywhere~included~middle~associative. See our What are Sophisms? page. |
Quantum~gn¤sis, when we acknowledge its emergent and adaptive evolutionary holographicityings, asks us to view quantum~truthings omnifferingly. Energy~wellings in any quantum~holograming coobsfect all local energy~wellings. Now fathom an energy~welling as a (i.e., one of many) enthymemetic quantum~m¤dal stochastic 'mode~node(s)' of quantum~truthing. Then we can easily grasp our local quantum~holograming as an ensemble of many quantum~energy~wellings' nodal truthings. Pneumatically, "Many Truthings." This is a way of showing how quantum~realityings are quantized (as n¤dal energy~wellings) evolutionary agents of choice, chance, and change whose massive heterogeneityings all emerge and adapt coherently but d¤ so energy~well by energy~well and d¤ it wholly asynchronously and quantum~ihndæpændæntly (Mae-wan Ho said "autonomously" which, to Doug, implies Finkelstein's quantum~c¤hærænt~islandicity) each having their own, n¤nglobal, timings...without any global isochrony, i.e., "Many Timings." Doug - 10Jan2010. |
substance is changeless except for analytic motion in space-time | substance may change continuously (at a Planck rate) | usually 'continuously' has a SOM analytic interpretation; here we intend a semantic of a quantized continuum |
substance pre-exists | actuality arises from nonactuality | and to complete this level of flux, actuality demises to nonactuality |
substance arranges itself into objects that are:
|
n/a |
in general, quantum models are:
SOM reality is a special, contrived and very limited case of quantum reality |
n/a |
coherence exists as quantum phenomena and minimally manifests quatrotomously:
|
See our Quanton Complementary Interrelationships |
n/a | quantum truth value is islandic-local and often nondistributive, noncommutative, nonfactorizable, and dependent on up to omni-possibilities | quantum reality is an omneity |
n/a | existence is an infinity of contexts | |
n/a | existence is a quantum stage | See our quantum stage stairways |