Arches

If you're stuck in a browser frame - click here to view this same page in Quantonics!

Doug Renselle's 2003-2004 Feuilleton Chautauqua
First Plateau:

Quantonics'
Bases of Judgment

"Understanding the logos enables judgment."
Heraclitus

See that 'the logos' AKA 'the account' link. Understanding that is crucial, crux for your progress in Quantonics. Read both sub-bullet items there.

Toosee qua.
(N¤t notsee, rather toosee! You can take your (dialectical) eyemuffs off! Doug - 30Mar2014.
Subdudes' nexus intentional. Nazi antinomial intentional.)

Note to students of Quantonics: All future revisions to this table will be done here.

Please adjust your font viewing size so that our quanton graphic's centerline below align's horizontal join of Dynamic and Static Quality cells.

1Kurt Gödel Collected Works Volume I, p. 6 of paperback with 474 total pages including index, OxUP, editors: Feferman et al., 1986.
2 Classically, a theory's complements do not exist and if they do they are innately 'false.' Quantumly, a theory's complements are EIMA agents of said theory's exegesis.
As an exercise, try interpreting that classical dogma in a social context of heterogeneous cultures: one societal theory as the societal theory.

By Doug Renselle — ©Quantonics, Inc., 2004-2029
Means: New~Revised
View Original Bases of Judgment

Bases
of
Judgment

Judgment Hierarchy

Quantonics
QTMs

Q
U
A
N
T
U
M

I
N
T
E
L
L
E
C
T
U
A
L

C
U
R
I
O
S
I
T
Y
 

MoQ
Valuation

CR
CTMs

SOM
CTMs

Emergent Good

Above Dynamic Good ·Physial novel emerscenture
·Requires emerscent linguistics for pragmathinking
·Requires acceptance of quantum evolution as real











Viewed (demoted by MoQ) as a subset of DQ phenomena Does not 'exist;' dialectically modeled as analytic, heterogeneous synthetic transformation Does not 'exist;' dialectically modeled as analytic, homogeneous synthetic transformation
Dynamic Good Above
Static
Good
·Physial absolute quantum flux; see QTMs
·Requires quantum linguistics for evolute thinking; see QELR
·AKA "quantum simplicity"

Dynamic Quality
Does not 'exist;' dialectically modeled as heterogeneous analytic (stoppable) motion Does not 'exist;' dialectically modeled as homogeneous analytic (stoppable) motion
Static Good Above Likelihood ·Physial uncertain quantum recursive persistency born of and mediated by Dynamic Good
·We call these quantum recursive persistencies "quantons"
·Quantons are stindyanic, EIMA both static and dynamic sorsos
·Static Good is above Likelihood since it is nature's quantum~vestal judgment; we and nature together are in quantum processings of ch3ing better nextings

Static Qualitycareful

·SQ SPoVs act in agency of DQ
·SQ SPoVs, prodded by DQ, assess and choose better at "the edge of now"

Demoted by CTMs as a dialectical subset of Heterogeneous Truth Demoted by CTMs as a dialectical subset of Homogeneous Truth

Likelihood
(stochastics: futurings)

Above Plausibility ·a priori (n¤n classical: quantum ¤mni prih¤hrai)
·quantum processings of looking at nextings given qualitative nowings
·quantum processings of looking at expected, anticipated nextings given qualitative nowings
·QLOings
·expectation of quantum plausibility omnistributionings
·ensemble nowings coobsfecting ensembling expectationings ch3ing whatings happenings nextings
·wave~emerqancings of ensemblings' nextings
Pirsig did not discuss 'likelihood' as an evolute of probability and plausibility in his SODV paper. Does not 'exist' classically since relative classical dialectical 'logic' is heterogeneous yet always looking at relative historical facts to obtain local (relative) decidability. Does not 'exist' classically since classical dialectical 'logic' is homogeneous and always looking at historical facts to obtain decidability.

Plausibility
(stochastics: nowings)

 Above Probability ·a iamai (n¤n classical: quantum ¤mni ihamaih)
·quantum processings of looking at both pastings and nowings given qualitative nowings
·evokings of quantum uncertainty given direct experiencings of nowings
·ensemble nowings coobsfecting ensembling nowings ch3ing whatings happenings nextings
·wave~emerqancings of ensemblings' nowings

Pirsig hints at this via his "many, unlimited hypotheses," "many truths," "many contexts," "Lila has Quality permits inferences of Quality has Lila," "All perspectives are partially right, i.e., 'all schools are right,'" "Mind is in Body and Body is in Mind," etc.

Spend some timings studying quantum~memes and ~memeos of quantum~partiality: crucial to Bases of Judgment as enthymemeticity (classically referred as 'partial logic' which Aristotle, et al., claimed 'false.'). HotMemeIn quantum~reality, all is partial. HotMeme™. All stochastics are only partial! Why? An evolving reality is always partially what it will be. An evolving reality is always uncertain about its own becoming. An evolving reality is indeterminate. An evolving reality cann¤t be dialectical! An evolving reality cann¤t become dialectical! Again, we remind our students of Paul Pietsch's words in his fabulous Shufflebrain, words slightly reordered for our use here, "The principal feature of intelligence is indeterminacy." For more on this essential quantum topic, see Doug's QELR of thought. Doug - 20Mar2008.

Depends upon relativistic ensembles; yet offers first CR hints of genuine quantum uncertainty. SOMites who use 'plausibility' aren't truepers. We see a glimmer of SOM denying its own fundamentals.

Probability
(stochastics: pastings)

Above Provability ·a posteriori (n¤n classical: quantum ¤mni p¤stærih¤raih)
·quantum processings of looking at pastings given qualitative nowings
·ensemble nowings coobsfecting historical ensemblings to predict (actually, we should say "select" here) a probability distribution of what will happen next.
·What is Wrong with Probability as Value?
·wave~emerqancings of ensemblings' pastings
Pirsig said in his SODV paper, "Probability is Value." Exists in relative classical dialectical 'logic' since relativity admits heterogeneous ensembles which may be used to assess probability.

Does not 'exist' classically since classical dialectical 'logic' is homogeneous and thus no single event can be probabilistically predicted. Probability requires an ensemble of nonunique events, and classical theory denies any heterogeneity in classical reality.

See cause.

Provability

Above Truth ·Absoluteness as quantum uncertainty
·Heterogeneous con(m)texts eliminate paradice
·Solomon Feferman says that Gödel "realized that analogous nonparadoxical arguments could be carried out by substituting the notion of provability for that of truth."1
·wave~emerqancings of ensemblings' comtextings
Pirsig apparently knew little of Gödel Nonconceptual notion in CTMs (i.e., as distinguishable from a dialectic notion of ideal EOOO true | false) Nonconceptual notion in CTMs (i.e., as distinguishable from a dialectic notion of ideal EOOO true | false)

Quantum Judgment

Classical Judgment

Judgment Hierarchy

Quantonics
QTMs

C
L
A
S
S
I
C
A
L

D
I
A
L
E
C
T
I
C
A
L

I
N
T
E
L
L
I
G
E
N
C
E

Q
U
O
T
I
E
N
T

MoQ
Valuation

CR
CTMs

SOM
CTMs
Truth Above Proof ·Hermeneutic subset of Static Good
·Requires quantumists to adhere rhetoric and pragmalogic AKA coquecigrues
·Heterogeneous cowithinitness
·Many Truths AKA in Latin, "omniplex veritas"
·Viewed (subsumed) by MoQ as a DQ-agent subset of SQ
·Heterogeneous relatively absolute predicate logic delusions
·Polylogical dialectic
·Homogeneous absolute predicate logic delusion
·Monological dialectic
·E.g., both Christianity and Islam believe that morality and ethics may be adjudged dialectically; that's how they absolutely decide who 'the infidels' are that is pure unadulterated fascism!
Proof Above Falsifiability ·Descriptioningsquantons(theoryi,theory_complementsj)2
·Requires quantum animate, heterogeneous, EIMA rhetoric in place of classical stable, homogeneous, EEMD dialectic
·Replaces classical dialectical EOOO fascism with quantum rhetorical BAWAM sophism
·Any notion of ideal proof is nonabsolute; dialectic is deeply flawed and weak
·MoQ claims dialectic is a subset of [quantum] rhetoric
·Viewed (subsumed) by MoQ as a DQ-agent subset of SQ
·Relative classical delusion of locally absolute truth based upon an assumption that SOM proof is valid Provisional classical delusion of a capability to assess absolute truth using a classical notion of proof based upon absolute dialectical falsifiability which depends upon ideal dialectical 'contradiction' based upon dialectically ideal formal and objective oppositional-negation

Falsifiability

Above Contradiction ·Only quantum umcærtainty may bæ established, ihn genæral. ·Pirsig does not say this explicitly, but one may infer that ideal classical falsifiability is impossible without an assumption of ideal classical contradiction. ·Relative classical delusion of locally absolute truth based upon an assumption that SOM falsifiability is valid ·Classical delusion that 'scientific' falsifiability may be established based upon ideal classical contradiction.

Contradiction

Above Negation ·Only ænsehmble quantum ihnterrelati¤nships ¤f ænsehmble quantum c¤mplæmænts may bæ ømniht¤red as anihmatæ EIMA quantum pr¤cessings.
·Ænsehmble quantum ihnterrelati¤nship m¤niht¤ring is, ihn Quantonics, what wæ mæan whæn wæ sahy, "quantum ¤mniht¤rmænt." Quantum ¤mniht¤rmænt ihnv¤lves what wæ cahll "straddling" since quantum ¤mniht¤rmænt ihnnatæly taps n¤nahctualihty AKA VES.
- Compare cancellation.
- Consider complementation.
- Fathom antinomialism.
·Pirsig does not say this explicitly, but one may infer that ideal classical contradiction is impossible without an assumption of ideal classical oppositional-negation. ·Relative classical delusion of locally absolute truth based upon an assumption that SOM contradiction is valid ·Classical delusion that logical contradiction may be established based upon ideal classical oppositional-negation.

Negation

Above Lisrability ·Quantum nægati¤n issi c¤mplæmæntary amd thuhs subqjæctihvæ, rhet¤rihcal, amd s¤phist. Why? Quantons aræ ænsehmble EIMA pærpætuahlly ch3ing pr¤cæssings.
·Quantum nægati¤n's c¤mplæmæntarihty issi pærhaps bæst exhibihted via mæmæs amd mæmæos ¤f quantum~wavæ p¤sihtih ænærgy cancællati¤n.
·See our QELR of oppositional-negation.
·Viewed classically, this notion of ideal oppositional-negation based upon ideal lisrability and ideal stability is what Pirsig calls "SOM's genetic defect in reason itself."
·MoQ sutures SOM's knife cut defect in classicism's "Church of Reason."
·Relative classical delusion of locally absolute (i.e., relative) truth based upon an assumption that SOM oppositional-negation is valid

·Classical delusion that oppositional-negation is 'objective.' Classical objectivity depends upon two more fundamental delusions:

  1. Reality is stable (holds still, is classically and ideally 'stoppable')
  2. Objects in reality are independent (this classical delusion is what we call SOM's schism, cut by SOM's dialectical 'knife' of 'reason')
 Lisrability Above Stability ·Quantons ihn quantum ræhlihty aræ n¤nlisrable amd ¤nly apparæntly lisrable.
·Quantons ihn quantum ræhlihty have arbihtrary spathial, tehmp¤ral, ænærgy~matærial, gravihtati¤nal, sæns¤rial, etc. pr¤babilihty ¤mnistrihbuti¤ns.
·Quantons ihn quantum ræhlihty have anihmatæ EIMA ihnterrelati¤nships which pærhaps may bæst bæ ¤mniscrihbæd as Poisson Brackets (AKA P.B.s).
·Pirsig's MoQ denies SOM's objective schism thus denying general validity of any classical notions of lisrability. ·Relative classical delusion of locally absolute truth based upon an assumption that SOM lisrability is valid ·SOM's next to most fundamental classical delusion: 'objects in reality are independent of one another.'
·Assumes reality adheres Aristotle's three syllogistic (rather, sillygisitic) 'laws.'
 Stability ·Quantum ræhlihty ¤ffers n¤ ideal classical stability.
·Quantum ræhlihty issi abs¤lutæly anihmatæ.
·Quantum flux is sihmplæ. Update - 10Jul2007 - Doug.
·See Doug's What is Simple? What is Complex?
·Pirsig's MoQ says that reality's essence is Dynamic Quality which denies any classical notions of ideal stability. ·Relative classical delusion of locally absolute truth based upon an assumption that SOM stability is valid ·SOM's most fundamental classical delusion: 'reality is stable.'

For example, 'A=A' implies ideal constancy — unless reality is quantum~animately EIMA~sophist~recursive.

·SOM's 'concrete reality.'
·AKA 'classical simplicity.'
·Juxtapose change as 'classical complexity.'
·See Bergson on static simplicity vis-à-vis dynamic simplicity.

Judgment Hierarchy

Quantonics
QTMs

MoQ
Valuation

MoQites' Monitorings
MoQites View Reality

CR
CTMs

CRites' Measures
CRites View Reality

SOM
CTMs

SOMites Measure
SOMites View Reality

By Doug Renselle — ©Quantonics, Inc., 2004-2029
(25Mar2004 rev - Extend MoQ Valuation Column.)
(27Mar2004 rev - Restore Pirsig-Godel cell's red background.)
(5May2004 rev - Add 'falsifiability,' 'contradiction,' 'oppositional-negation,' 'lisrability,' and 'stability' to Bases of Judgment Table.)
(10May2004 rev - Minor unhighlighted corrections and additions near page bottom.)
(11May2004 rev - Add 'likelihood,' and 'probability' to Bases of Judgment Table.)
(12May2004 rev - Add link-anchors to footnotes. Add "quantum simplicity" bullet item to QTM's Dynamic Good.)
(12May2004 rev - Extend QTM's Static Good. Add a 'concrete' bullet item to SOM's Stability.)
(17May2004 rev - Refine non classical quantum memeos of a priori and a posteriori.)
(23May2004 rev - Add wave~emerqancings to provability, probability, and likelihood.)
(13Jul2004 rev - Remove legacy red update marks. Add some extended red text.)
(2Sep2004 rev - Reformat table. Reset red text and arrows.)
(18Sep2004 rev - Slightly alter Quantonic 'oppositional-negation' description.')
(25Dec2004 rev - Add column titles at page bottom. Reset legacy marks.)
(13Feb2005 rev - Upgrade CTM SOM Probability.)
(14Feb2005 rev - Add column titles at page middle.)
(1Mar2005 rev - Add 'coquecigrues' link.)
(17Mar2005 rev - Add quantum monitor link under 'contradiction.' Add six new links in bottom title row.)
(29Jun2005 rev- Add blue and yellow intellectual bars.)
(8Jan2006 rev - Repair 'lisr' link.)
(23Feb2006 rev - Add 'plausibility.' Needed for exegesis of PNFings QLO temporalings.)
(4Sep2006 rev - Add 'omnitor' link. Reset red text updates.)
(18Oct2006 rev - Add Bergson 'delusion' anchors.)
(17Nov2006 rev - Add 'lisr' link under 'Lisrability.')
(14Jan2008 rev - Add link to our new QELR of 'partial' under 'plausibility.' Add comments on partiality as enthymemetic. Add 'Plausibility' anchor.)
(12Mar2008 rev - Update Quantonics QTM cell under oppositional-negation. Reset legacy red text. Updated that same cell even more.)
(19Aug2008 rev - Add 23Apr2006 update text from list below to this list for clarity of actual table maintenance.)
(6Feb2011 rev - Repair link to Doug's recent "What is Simple? What is Complex? Why? Explain.")
(22Aug2012 rev - Add 'cancellation' link under 'contradiction.')


To contact Quantonics write to or call:

Doug Renselle
Quantonics, Inc.
Suite 18 #368 1950 East Greyhound Pass
Carmel, INdiana 46033-7730
USA
1-317-THOUGHT

©Quantonics, Inc., 2004-2029 — Rev. 11Jul2015  PDR — Created 21-25Mar2004  PDR
(27Mar2004 rev - Edit table.)
(5May2004 rev - Extend bottom of table with five new rows.)
(10May2004 rev - Minor table updates.)
(11May2004 rev - Extend upper middle of table with two new rows.)
(12May2004 rev - Table footnotes' links-anchors.)
(17May2004 rev - Table comtent refinements.)
(23May2004 rev - Extend provability, probability, and likelihood. Add top and bottom Arches links.)
(13Jul2004 rev - Reset marks. Add red text.)
(22Jul2004 rev - Update MoQ's many truths for Latin version.)
(23Jul2004 rev - Adjust table width to narrower.)
(2Sep2004 rev - Set table width and cells to variable.)
(18Sep2004 rev - Extend Quantonic description under 'oppositional-negation.')
(19Sep2004 rev - Extend Quantonic description under 'contradiction.')
(3Nov2004 rev - Add 'SOM's Bases of Judgment' anchor to SOM's yellow cells.)
(25Dec2004 rev - Update table format.)
(13-14Feb2005 rev - Clarify our exegesis of 'CTM Probability. See white text with red background. Update table format.)
(1Mar2005 rev - Add 'coquecigrues' link under [truth,QTM] cell.)
(17Mar2005 rev - Add quantum monitor link under 'contradiction.' Add six new links in bottom title row.)
(29Jun2005 rev - Reformat table and remove legacy red text updates.)
(9Sep2005 rev - Add 'quantum~vestal' phrase under QTM's 'static good.' Borne of reading F. A. Yates' The Art of Memory on G. Bruno, p. 290 of 400 total.)
(24Sep2005 rev - In 'Static Good' row under MoQ column add 'choose better' link to our QELR of 'select.')
(1,18Oct2005 rev - Add anchor to 1st occurrence of 'SOM's knife.' Minor grammatical adjustment of QTM 'probability.')
(8,27Jan2006 rev - Repair table link. Demarcate quantum judgment up and classical judgment down.)
(23Feb2006 rev - Add 'plausibility.' Needed for exegesis of PNFings QLO temporalings.)
(24May2006 rev - Add link to QELR of 'fact.')
(4Sep2006 rev - Update 'Negation' in table.)
(18,20Oct2006 rev - Update Bergson 'stability,' and 'independence' delusion cells with anchors. Add 'stochastics' anchor.)
(17Nov2006 rev - Alter 'Lisrability' in table.)
(17Jan2007 rev - Add page top title window Heraclitus quote.)
(27Apr2007 rev - Add 'Quantum Stochastic Judgment' anchor.)
(10Jul2007 rev - Update 'quantum stability.' Add QTM and CTM acronym links near SOM Bases of Judgment anchor.)
(19Sep2007 rev - Repair
PPL omnis' QELR present participlings.)
(14Jan2008 rev - Add link to our new QELR of 'partial' under 'plausibility.' Add comments on partiality as enthymemetic. Add 'Plausibility' anchor.)
(16Feb2008 rev - Add 'contradiction' anchor and embolden those terms in that row bright red. Reformat some cell background colors.)
(12,20Mar2008 rev - Update table. Update table.)
(14,19Aug2008 rev - Reformat. Copy 23Apr2006 history markup to table edit list for maintenance clarity. Need both edit lists for a full pix of maintenance history!)
(14Nov2010 rev - Reset legacy markups. Make page current.)
(9Jan2011 rev - Edit table for 'What is Simple? What is Complex? Why? Explain.')
(6Feb2011 rev - Repair that new, "What is Simple? What is Complex? Why? Explain," link.)
(22,25Aug2012 rev - Add 'cancellation' link under 'contradiction.' Add page top 'the logos' link.)
(18Sep2013 rev - Make page current. Reset legacy markups.)
(30Mar2014 rev - Change all 'negation' occurrences to 'oppositional-negation.' Add link to 'antinomial' as quantum~remediation for 'oppositional-negation.')
(24Dec2014 rev - Make page current. Adjust color.)
(11Jul2015 rev - Add links to 'logic' and 'truth' under Truth and Proof.)


Arches